DISQUS

Art of Manliness: 5 Personal Finance Discussions To Have Before Getting Hitched

  • Kevin (ReturnToManliness) · 1 year ago
    The one point everyone has to remember is to NOT be judgmental towards the other person for having issues. They may have made mistakes in the past and want a chance to fix them.

    The separate accounts issue is kinda like a pre-nup...this one can cause some problems with the whole "our love is forever" thing. If she says "don't you think we are going to be together forever?" and/or "well then, what's the point of getting married?", it's time to ease up a little and try a different approach...learned from experience...
  • Wil · 1 year ago
    I am just over 4 months on my marriage, and I have found that mint.com has helped us both get a solid graphical grip on where our money is going, and it does it without the hard work of entering everything into the spreadsheet. Oh and it is also free, and not ad supported, but offer and anyo-data supported so a really clean interface.
  • Nesagwa · 1 year ago
    Hey, thanks for the link Wil. That looks much better than the old Quickbooks type program.
  • John · 1 year ago
    Being married for almost a year now, I tend to agree with the idea of drafting a buget together. It helps both husband and wife see in a concrete way where the money goes. This in turn stays fresh in your mind when you are about to buy something on impulse. The key to this is to review the budget frequently, even weekly so that husband and wife can develop solid financial habits.
  • Brett McKay · 1 year ago
    @ Will- I'm a big fan of Mint as well. However, some of my bank accounts have trouble working with it. They don't update. So, I've been using the spreadsheet program until it gets cleared up.
  • John · 1 year ago
    My wife and I have separate joint accounts. That is, we have each other's names on our separate accounts. It makes things easier for us, since we split up the bills, and we don't generally have to worry about accidentally causing overdrafts. In addition, should something happen to either of us, the other spouse will have access to all accounts without having to jump through hoops.

    John (another one)
  • Hayden Tompkins · 1 year ago
    FYI, there are two types of finances to manage - household and investment.

    I manage the household finances (budgeting, money allocation, food purchases, etc.), though he pays our joint bills.

    He also manages our investments. Me? I just say 'dump it in an index fund', but he prefers to much more involved than that! So he does it.
  • pistolette · 1 year ago
    A friend of mine had awful debt, and her boyfriend said he wouldn't marry her until she got out of it. He taught her how to be responsible, and enjoy life without excessive spending. I used to think he was a jerk, but now I realize it was kind of romantic, like saving her from a drug addiction. She did get out of debt, and they are married now, have a nice investment portfolio, and own a pretty cabin in the woods :-)
  • angelina · 1 year ago
    A friend of mine had awful debt, and her boyfriend said he wouldn't marry her until she got out of it. He taught her how to be responsible, and enjoy life without excessive spending. I used to think he was a jerk, but now I realize it was kind of romantic, like saving her from a drug addiction. She did get out of debt, and they are married now, have a nice investment portfolio, and own a pretty cabin in the woods :-)
  • Brett McKay · 1 year ago
    @ Hayden- That sounds like a good arrangement. I'm with you on the dump it in an index fund philosophy.

    @ angelina- I'm glad to hear that it worked out for your friend and her husband. I hope to get my financial situation to a position where I can own a cabin in the woods, too.
  • Helen · 1 year ago
    I worked in a credit union 27 plus years ago and was told by the financial advisor to get my own checking account and a major credit card in my name only. He said "every married woman needs those two" I followed his advise and tell other women the same thing.
  • Shanel Yang · 1 year ago
    One more to add to your list: Talk about a prenup. I know, I know. No one wants to hear that one. But, see why everyone (even those who aren't rich) need one in article "Who Needs Prenups?" at http://shanelyang.com/2008/07/11/who-needs-pren...
  • theBorch · 1 year ago
    Mint.com is a great site to help with your finances, has fancy graphs and everything, best of all it's still free!
  • Sean · 1 year ago
    YNAB (you need a budget) .com saved my marriage. A month after we were married my wife admitted that she'd racked up some serious debt from a bad business decision years ago and had been trying to dig herself out unsuccessfully ever since. She declared bankruptcy and I watched my dreams of homeownership fall away like burnt ash.
    I have never been the most financially savvy man in the world (Which I owe to my folks who were always very quiet about money when I was growing up) and It wasn't until my wife and I sat down and started working on YNAB together that we began to see eye to eye about our goals with money. We now work out a budget at the beginning of each month and then spend a few minutes each Friday entering expenses in the program. It helps us keep each other honest and moving forward on our savings and financial goals.
    If you're like many of the baby boomers' children and didn't get a solid financial education growing up then I can't recommend something like YNAB enough for getting you in touch with money.
  • Richard · 1 year ago
    One thing I only realized recently is that budgeting software and financial accounting software are different! In the past we used accounting software thinking that we were budgeting, but it didn't really help. Now we're using a spreadsheet and doing budgeting.

    In general:

    Financial accounting software will let you see where your money is going (and where it went), but it doesn't tell you where it's going to go. eg. Quicken, http://www.gnucash.org/

    Budgeting software tells you how much you have and where it's supposed to go, but won't tell you where it has been going. eg. http://www.youneedabudget.com/
  • Eric · 1 year ago
    Giving up control over anything that's been your sole responsibility can be tough. Understanding the difference between giving up control and sharing responsibility, though, is one of the most important parts of any relationship.

    You would never enter a business contract with someone who wasn't willing to shoulder the responsibility for the relationship equally. Likewise, you wouldn't want to enter a marriage where either party ignores the joint financial commitment.

    Discussing money is never fun, particularly when it can so easily become a wedge between to people. At the same time, the money conversation is just as important as the kids conversation leading up to the decision to get married.
  • fathersez · 1 year ago
    This is a subject I have wanted to broach to my children (my elder 2 girls) for some time now.

    Your post has made it much easier for me. Thanks
  • Israel · 1 year ago
    I did all of these before getting married. I was glad I did because it helped us solidify our finances at the time.
  • HL · 1 year ago
    There are definitely some issues here. For one thing, you sure don't need a pre-nup. And any marriage counselor will tell you that if you keep separate bank accounts then you're marriage is already in trouble. The whole point of marriage is a life long commitment. If you go into with the idea that you can get out of it at some point and save yourself some money, then you aren't really committing, and it sure won't be for life. You have to realize that your money is no longer 'your' money. It is 'our' money. To treat it any differently is an insult to your spouse.

    My wife is a stay at home mother. Does that mean that she can't have any money at all? Heck, it's 'MY' money, I earned it! If she wants to spend something, she can go out and get her own money! I don't think so.

    Believe it or not, a woman can actually survive after her husband is dead, even if they only had one joint account.

    All that crap aside, you absolutely must communicate with each other about the budget. Money problems can be really hard on a marriage, but you are in it together. Everything is together. You are now one flesh. Communicate about everything.
  • M. Steve · 1 year ago
    "The guy is kind of a douchebag when he says he wouldn’t have married his wife if he knew her credit report."

    I go much further that that. I find that commercial morally offensive, as if the marker of whether you should marry someone is a score assigned by a corporation. He even says, "I married my dream girl", but, instead of being incredibly happy and thankful, and together working through her past mistakes, he sits whining and wishing had his dream house, instead. Not much of a man, methinks. He should-a spent some time reading your blog.

    (I actually didn't see that commercial for a long time, and figured they pulled it cause even freecreditreport.com saw how disgusting the message is, but it's back. Can't say that I'm surprised.)
  • Jim · 1 year ago
    Not to sound prudish, but aren't you contradicting yourself a bit with your sentence, "The guy is kind of a douchebag when he says he wouldn’t have married his wife if he knew her credit report. "

    Don't you preach that a man should use a certain level of decorum in his communications?

    Taken from your book:
    "Avoid profane language. Profanity is a mark of low breeding. If
    you must swear, avoid doing so in front of ladies and small children."

    Perhaps you are taking the viewpoint that ladies and small children do not frequent this site; I also understand that "douchebag" may not necessarily be considered a profanity, but it is not a word I would use in front of a woman.

    Please understand, I would bet that I use profanity more than the average person, I was just surprised to see it in your posting.

    Just my two cents...
  • Brett · 1 year ago
    @Jim-

    I admittedly use "douche bag" a lot in both my writing and my verbal communications. Perhaps it is a weakness, but truth be told, I just find the word really amusing. It doesn't seem crass to me, it just makes me chuckle. I do use it around most women, although I probably wouldn't around children. The former do read the blog, while I doubt the latter do. To me douche bag it up there with "damn" and "hell" which aren't grievous swears and instead can be use to pepper your communications now and then. But I respect that everyone's tolerance level for certain words is different and every man must make up his own mind about which words are appropriate.
  • Jim · 1 year ago
    @Brett

    Perhaps I was being a bit of a prude; however I have been frequenting the AOM quite often lately and am trying to curb certain habits. I do believe that there is something to be said about a man who understands the art of being a gentleman. I also believe that many of the women that I know appreciate a man that understands this "art".

    G-d knows that I use plenty of foul language in front of people (women included). It is something that I am trying to control moving forward. Maybe this was a personal case of the pendulum swinging from one extreme to the other.
  • Adam · 1 year ago
    I personally find that using the google spreadsheet program works the best for doing the budget because it is easy to work on it together from two seperate computers at the same time. It also keeps a history of the changes that have occurred to the budget spreadsheet as well.